| 62. | 2024 | York, PA | Four Points by Sheraton |
| 61. | 2023 | Terrell, TX | Fairfield Inn and Suites |
| 60. | 2022 | Lexington, SC | Comfort Suites |
| 59. | 2021 | Jefferson City, MO | Capitol Plaza Hotel & Convention Center |
59. | 2020 | Jefferson City, MO | (Postponed due to COVID-19) |
| 58. | 2019 | Dover, DE | Holiday Inn |
| 57. | 2018 | Fredericksburg, VA | Fredericksburg Hospitality House Hotel / Conference Ctr. |
| 56. | 2017 | Reno, NV | Best Western Airport Plaza Hotel |
| 55. | 2016 | Sarasota, FL | Hilton Garden Inn |
| 54. | 2015 | Tiffin, Ohio | Hampton Inn |
| 53. | 2014 | Colorado Springs, CO | DoubleTree Hotel |
| 52. | 2013 | Johnson City, TN | Holiday Inn |
| 51. | 2012 | Branson, MO | Grand Plaza Hotel |
| 50. | 2011 | Easton, MD | Comfort Inn |
| 49. | 2010 | New London, CT | Radisson |
| 48. | 2009 | Waco, TX | Clarion Hotel |
| 47. | 2008 | Everett, WA | Best Western Cascadia Inn |
| 46. | 2007 | Huntsville, AL | Country Hearth Inn, Madison |
| 45. | 2006 | Denver, CO | DoubleTree Hotel |
| 44. | 2005 | Fremont, OH | Fremont Holiday Inn |
| 43. | 2004 | Sarasota, FL | Hilton Garden Inn |
| 42. | 2003 | St. Louis, MO | Univ. of Missouri, St. Louis |
| 41. | 2002 | Salt Lake City, UT | Best Western Salt Lake Plaza |
| 40. | 2001 | Linthicum, MD | BWI Comfort Inn |
| 39. | 2000 | Baton Rouge, LA | Holiday Inn South |
| 38. | 1999 | Great Falls, MT | Heritage Inn Best Western |
| 37. | 1998 | Windsor Locks, CT | Doubletree Hotel |
| 36. | 1997 | Asheville, NC | Radisson Hotel Asheville |
| 35. | 1996 | Oberlin, OH | Oberlin College |
| 34. | 1995 | Muskogee, OK | Ramada Inn |
| 33. | 1994 | Everett, WA | Cypress Inn |
| 32. | 1993 | Denver, CO | Best Western |
| 31. | 1992 | Daytona Beach, FL | Desert Inn |
| 30. | 1991 | Peoria, IL | Jumer's Castle Lodge |
| 29. | 1990 | Reno, NV | Sands Hotel |
| 28. | 1989 | Jessup, MD | Holiday Inn |
| 27. | 1988 | Ridgecrest, CA | Heritage Inn |
| 26. | 1987 | Sandusky, OH | Sheraton Sandusky Hotel |
| 25. | 1986 | Racine, WI | Sheraton Racine Hotel |
| 24. | 1985 | Syracuse, NY | LeMoyne College |
| 23. | 1984 | Albuquerque, NM | Classic Hotel |
| 22. | 1983 | Lansing, MI | Hilton Inn |
| 21. | 1982 | Seattle, WA | Rodeway Inn |
| 20. | 1981 | Bloomington, IL | Illinois Wesleyan Univ |
| 19. | 1980 | Annapolis Jct, MD | Quality Inn, Colony 7 |
| 18. | 1979 | St. Petersburg, FL | Don Cesar Motel |
| 17. | 1978 | Goshen, IN | Goshen College |
| 16. | 1977 | San Diego, CA | Royal Inn at the Wharf |
| 15. | 1976 | Philadelphia, PA | Benjamin Franklin Hotel |
| 14. | 1975 | Wenham, MA | Gordon College |
| 13. | 1974 | College Park, MD | Interstate Inn |
| 12. | 1973 | Findlay, OH | Imperial House Motel |
| 11. | 1972 | Des Moines, IA | Hotel Fort Des Moines |
| 10. | 1971 | Poultney, VT | Green Mountain College |
| 9. | 1970 | Evansville, IN | Ramada Inn |
| 8. | 1969 | Findlay, OH | Imperial House Motel |
| 7. | 1968 | Newark, NJ | Robert Treat Hotel |
| 6. | 1967 | Omaha, NE | Schimel's Indian Hills Inn |
| 5. | 1966 | Cleveland, OH | Wilson's Motor Hotel |
| 4. | 1965 | Sarnia, Ont. | Drawbridge Inn |
| 3. | 1964 | St. Louis, MO | Statler Hilton Hotel |
| 2. | 1963 | Columbiana, OH | Pfund Farm |
| 1. | 1962 | Columbiana, OH | Pfund Farm |